RENEWABLE ENERGY:
A Record in Converting Photons to Fuel
Robert F. Service
It's the ultimate in clean energy: Generate fuel from
water using only the
power of sunlight, and when the fuel burns, it gives
off nothing but water.
Outlandish as it sounds, the dream was accomplished decades
ago by using
solar energy to split water into its components, oxygen
and hydrogen--a
powerful fuel that can be used to run everything from
power plants to cars.
But as a commercial proposition, the process has been
a nonstarter because
it's so inefficient and expensive. The two steps involved--generating
electricity from sunlight and using it to split water--normally
take place
in separate devices, and energy is lost in between.
Now on page 425, researchers at the National Renewable
Energy Laboratory
(NREL) in Golden, Colorado, have come up with a single
device that
accomplishes both tasks and has set a world record in
efficiency for
converting photons to fuel. The new solar-powered water
splitter, built by
NREL chemists John Turner and Oscar Khaselev, converts
about 12.5% of the
energy in sunlight to gaseous fuel--nearly double the
previous record
achieved by a conventional two-step process.
Marye Anne Fox, a chemist at the University of Texas,
Austin, calls this
efficiency "impressive." Fox's UT colleague Adam Heller
adds that the new
device avoids one pitfall common to conventional solar
water splitters: It
doesn't require the additional external energy that others
need to get the
job done. The NREL device "is a stand-alone cell that
is nicely efficient
and no longer needs external energy," says Heller. "It's
a nice milestone."
Even so, it's not about to catalyze a wholesale switch
from fossil fuels to
hydrogen, because the semiconductors at the heart of
the new devices are
expensive; they are currently used only for specialized
applications, such
as powering satellites.
Splitting water to create gaseous hydrogen and oxygen
is quite simple.
Stick a pair of metal electrodes into water, apply a
voltage across them,
and presto, oxygen gas is liberated at one electrode
and hydrogen gas at
the other. The process, known as electrolysis, is commonly
used to produce
pure hydrogen for making everything from food oils to
computer chips. But
it's expensive and requires fossil fuels to generate
the electricity that
powers the process. So energy researchers have long dreamed
of using solar
energy to drive the electrolysis.
The basic principle of generating electricity from sunlight
is, again, well
known. When photons from sunlight strike normally static
electrons in some
semiconductor materials, they kick the electrons into
a higher energy
level, allowing them to roam about. Left behind are electron
vacancies, or
"holes," that act like positive charges that can also
migrate through the
material. Additional semiconductor layers on either side
of the absorbing
layer then channel the electrons and holes in opposite
directions, creating
an electric current that can perform work or be stored
in a battery. But,
unfortunately, combining this so-called photovoltaic
effect with
electrolysis in a single device isn't simple.
First, there's a compatibility problem. Solar cells must
sit in water in
order to split it into hydrogen and oxygen, but semiconductors
that are
efficient light absorbers are often unstable in water.
Then there's the
energy problem. A water molecule splits into hydrogen
and oxygen atoms only
if each atom absorbs electrical charges packing very
precise--and
different--amounts of energy. In conventional electrolysis,
the metal
electrodes carry electrical charges with a wide energy
range, allowing
those with just the right amount of energy to catalyze
the split. But
semiconductors are more finicky. Charges in these materials
can exist only
at well-defined energy levels, and "nature has not been
kind to us in this
instance," says Turner. The only semiconductor materials
that produce
electrical charges at just the right levels to generate
both hydrogen and
oxygen are very poor absorbers of sunlight.
To overcome these problems, Turner and Khaselev constructed
a sandwichlike
device that pairs the talents of two different semiconductor
materials.
One--made from gallium indium phosphide--absorbs ultraviolet
and visible
light and produces mobile electrons with the right energy
to produce
hydrogen. The other--made from gallium arsenide--absorbs
infrared light and
produces holes with the right amount of energy to produce
oxygen. Gallium
indium phosphide is stable in water, so it can be used
directly as an
electrode. But the unstable gallium arsenide layer is
sealed with a
transparent epoxy coating to protect it, and the holes
are shuttled to a
separate platinum electrode.
Although the new device appears to be efficient and stable,
Turner
estimates that it would produce hydrogen at three times
the cost of the
cheapest method for bulk production of hydrogen, in which
hydrogen atoms
are stripped from natural gas by superheated steam. Turner
and his
colleagues are now trying to engineer cheaper semiconductors
to perform the
water-splitting reaction. If they succeed, the energy
of the future may
finally find its way to the present.
Volume 280, Number 5362 Issue of 17 April 1998, p 382
©1998 by The American Association for the Advancement
of Science.